YardFit Pools

Above Ground Pool Reviews: Every Model We’ve Scored

On this page
  1. Intex Pool Reviews
  2. Bestway Pool Reviews
  3. Coleman Pool Reviews
  4. Summer Waves Pool Reviews
  5. Premium & Specialty Pool Reviews
  6. How to Read Our Reviews

Last updated: August 2026 • All reviews include Setup-Difficulty Score, Liner-Durability Score, and Yard-Fit Tag

Every review on this site assigns two numeric scores to the pool: a Setup-Difficulty Score (1–5, lower = easier) and a Liner-Durability Score (1–5, higher = tougher). We also assign a Yard-Fit Tag based on the pool’s actual footprint, leveling tolerance, and liner construction. No affiliate-inflated star ratings.

Intex Pool Reviews

Pool ModelBest ForSetup ScoreLiner Score
Intex Ultra XTR Frame PoolBest overall 3–5 season pool3/54/5
Intex Prism Frame Premium PoolBest mid-range / easiest setup2/53/5
Intex Metal Frame PoolBudget entry-level frame pool2/52/5
Intex Easy Set PoolBest inflatable / patio / rental1/52/5
Intex Greywood Premium PoolDeck-adjacent, wood-look aesthetic4/53/5

Bestway Pool Reviews

Pool ModelBest ForSetup ScoreLiner Score
Bestway Power Steel Pool (Round)Best value mid-range pool3/53/5
Bestway Power Steel Oval PoolBest oval for narrow yards4/53/5
Bestway Hydrium PoolBest Bestway for durability3/54/5
Bestway Steel Pro MAX PoolBest Bestway for families3/53/5

Coleman Pool Reviews

Pool ModelBest ForSetup ScoreLiner Score
Coleman Power Steel PoolTarget in-store buyers; oval option3/53/5

Summer Waves Pool Reviews

Pool ModelBest ForSetup ScoreLiner Score
Summer Waves Elite Frame PoolBest Summer Waves; small yard pick2/53/5
Summer Waves Active Frame PoolBudget entry-level pool2/52/5

Premium & Specialty Pool Reviews

Pool ModelBest ForSetup ScoreLiner Score
Doughboy Pioneer PoolBest for 10–20 year ownership4/55/5
Wilbar Saltwater-Ready PoolBest for saltwater systems3/54/5
Funsicle Oasis PoolBest for cold climates / Canada3/54/5

How to Read Our Reviews

  • Setup-Difficulty Score 1–2/5: one adult, under 3 hours. Realistic solo project.
  • Setup-Difficulty Score 3/5: two adults required for at least some steps. Half-day project.
  • Setup-Difficulty Score 4–5/5: two adults required throughout. Full day or professional install.
  • Liner-Durability Score 2/5: 1–2 season lifespan. Budget/inflatable tier.
  • Liner-Durability Score 3/5: 2–3 season lifespan. Mid-range tier.
  • Liner-Durability Score 4/5: 3–5 season lifespan. Premium tier.
  • Liner-Durability Score 5/5: 7–10 season lifespan. Resin frame pools only.

➜ How scores are calculated